Alan Ziegler

How did you become a writer? 

My identity as a writer was forged in fifth grade because I couldn’t sing (or so the music teacher determined). He selected all but five to be in the chorus, and my classroom teacher (perhaps to soften the blow) made us the newspaper staff. I wrote song lyrics (influenced by Dylan, Phil Ochs, Tim Buckley, and the like) and journalism throughout college, until the spring of my senior year (1970), when I began writing fragmentary poems (influenced by Richard Brautigan) during respites from anti-war protests. An English professor told me the poems “weren’t good but you could become a good poet.” Two days after graduation I was a reporter on a daily newspaper, which lasted only a few months. A senior editor advised me to get out and “be a writer” while I was young and could deal with insecurities and frustrations. He pointed to an aging colleague and said, “He waited too long before he quit. Went to New York, thought he’d write for The New Yorker. He forgot to clear his plan with them. Came back with his tail between his legs.” I went (back) to New York, and many times I had my tail between my legs, but I never had the nerve to quit.

Name your writing influences (writers, books, teachers, etc.).

In college, Professor Jocelyn Harvey introduced me to the Imagist poets and the legitimacy of colloquial language in poetry. David Ignatow was my first mentor and, since he had been a protégé of William Carlos Williams, I consider WCW to be my grandmentor. I also studied with Kurt Vonnegut, who said I was becoming “a man of letters” (which continues to fuel me); Joel Oppenheimer, who encouraged me to become “less of a tummler and more of a poet”; and William Burroughs, who didn’t say much beyond his presence. Baudelaire’s Paris Spleen and Max Jacob’s The Dice Cup are two of the most influential books. Other writers include James Baldwin, James Tate, Borges, Luisa Valenzuela, Sei Shōnagon, Paul Krassner (for inventive journalism), and, later, the flash trinity: Diane Williams, Amy Hempel, and Lydia Davis.

When and where do you write? 

I often take catwrites during the day: a few minutes here and there, perhaps in the rear corner seat of a New York City bus. Sustained sessions usually start at home, until the choice becomes to nap or go to a café (I know I’m in a groove when the café wins). I like having the TV or radio on in the background—the sound disappears while I’m concentrating, and it’s nice to have the company when I pause. On the night Kafka wrote “The Judgment,” he last looked at the clock at 2 a.m.; when the maid arrived—with the bed “undisturbed”—he stretched and declared, “I’ve been writing until now.” A version of that—minus the maid—occasionally happens for me.  I can never write before I teach: even if I’m not scrambling to get ready for class (which I usually am), my focus is outward.

What are you working on now? 

For many years I’ve been writing short memory pieces, with the hope that eventually they would morph into a book. I think I’m close to that happening, with the working title Based on a True Life: A Memoir of Sorts. I’ve also been working on Squibs, a collection of fragments. My fantasy is for the two books to be published as a boxed set. Many of the pieces in both manuscripts can be found on The Best American Poetry blog, which is my write-to place: Ziegler at Best American Poetry. I’ve also resumed writing songs, collaborating with Steve Noonan (one of the Orange County Three, along with Tim Buckley and Jackson Browne): In My Dream

Have you ever suffered from writer’s block?

Three or four times a day, but rarely for many days in a row. 

What’s the best writing advice you’ve ever received?

I crossed paths with the poet Gerald Stern, who spent a couple of days at the Interlochen Arts Academy when I was writer-in-residence. Over lunch, I gave him a book of my poetry, and at dinner he had some nice things to say about it. He especially liked a poem that I had added to the manuscript out of fondness though I wasn’t sure it would hold up to critical scrutiny. I asked Stern why he liked the poem, hoping he would articulate some literary quality to support my fondness for it, and he replied, “Because I got the feeling you didn’t know what the hell you were doing.” I did feel affirmed, and this attitude has helped me spawn many subsequent pieces. I treasure the luscious feeling I get when I don’t know what the hell I am doing but I really want to keep doing it.

What’s your advice to new writers?

Yes, writing has its pitfalls and pratfalls. Dorothy Parker (among others) has been quoted as saying that she hates writing but loves having written. I was a bit milder when I used to say (thinking I was the first), “I don’t always like writing but I love having written.” Now, more and more, I cherish the act of writing as its own reward. I try not to focus on the value of my creations so much that I lose touch with the joy of creation. The opinions of others and the occasional attendant perks remain coveted, but are not essential. Here’s the advice: Write because you love writing, even if you don’t always like what you have written.

Alan Ziegler’s books include Love At First Sight: An Alan Ziegler Reader; The Swan Song of Vaudeville: Tales and Takes; and The Writing Workshop Note Book. He is the editor of Short: An International Anthology of 500 Years of Short-Short Stories, Prose Poems, Brief Essays, and Other Short Prose Forms (Persea Books), and his work has appeared in such places as The New Yorker, The Paris Review, and Tin House. He is Professor of Writing (and former chair) at Columbia University’s School of the Arts, where he received the Presidential Award for Outstanding Teaching.

Tom Rosenstiel

How did you become a writer?

I think I always knew somehow. My sixth grade teacher--who was great--told me I would be a writer; that made an impression. Then there were other tectonic forces. A lot of support from other teachers. Then, at the awkward age of 15, a senior recruited me to work on the school paper and I was hooked on journalism...edited the high school and college papers. I always wanted to write fiction, but I was a journalist for many years and had a lot of success writing nonfiction. But the compulsion to write novels never left me. I returned to it in my 50s.

Name your writing influences (writers, books, teachers, etc.). 

So many it’s hard to name them. Among thriller writers, Henning Menkel and Ian Rankin are favorites. So are Sara Paretsky and Michael Connelly. Before that, many of the classical crime writers: James M. Cain, Dashiell Hammett and Raymond Chandler. Outside the genre, Wallace Stegner, Hemingway, E.M. Forester and the king of kings: Tolstoy. Not very original. I guess there is a reason they are influential.

When and where do you write? 

First thing in the morning, as early as I can wake. I used to write everywhere around my house. That led to spine surgery. Now I have a writing room, a small converted bedroom, ergonomically organized, huge screen, trying to save my body. But I now try to do the first bad drafts fast--in longhand--so I don't fiddle so much.

What are you working on now?

My third novel, called Oppo, about the next presidential campaign, is done. I’m now starting a fourth about the launch of a new presidency and the efforts of a maverick if reckless politician--not Trump--to tackle climate change. Yeah, its a little weird to write political fiction when the news reads like dystopian fiction.

Have you ever suffered from writer’s block? 

What’s that?

What’s the best writing advice you’ve ever received?

From Walter Mosley's wonderful small book on writing (and most other professional writers I have met): Write everyday. No matter what. Humphrey Bogart supposedly once said, "A professional is someone who does his (let's use the plural pronoun they) best work when they least want to." Sounds about right.

What’s your advice to new writers?

Don’t give up. Believe in yourself. Believe in yourself. Don’t give up.

Bio: A journalist in Washington, I was press critic at the LA Times for a decade, chief congressional correspondent at Newsweek and a press critic at MSNBC. I was a cofounder of the Pew Research Center, where I ran the media research for 16 years. I am now executive director of the American Press Institute and a senior non-resident fellow at the Brookings Institution. I’ve written seven nonfiction books, including the Elements of Journalism, which is been translated into more than 25 languages. My first novel, Shining City, was published when I was 60, in 2017. Don’t give up.

Lori Gottlieb

How did you become a writer?

I think I became a writer by being a reader. Books were my salvation growing up. I never thought I'd grow up to be a writer, though, because I didn't know anyone who did that kind of job. I loved story in all forms--books, TV, film, plays, radio, conversations with friends. After college I worked as a development executive in film and later moved over to network TV. I hung out in the emergency room with the medical consultant for the show ER, and eventually decided to apply to  medical school. While I was looking through my closets in my parents' house for my old high school science notes so I could prepare for the MCAT, I came across my childhood diaries and a friend suggested that they'd make a great book. When that book was published, I started writing for magazines and newspapers and then wrote another book, and another, and after doing that for years, one day I woke up and finally said to myself, "I guess I became a writer." 

Name your writing influences (writers, books, teachers, etc.).

I've always admired a masterful memoir, one that made me see myself or the world differently through somebody else's experience. Or one that gave voice to something I'd always felt or thought but hadn't quite articulated to myself in that way. Same thing with novels and their psychological insights and ability to make me feel less alone in my own struggles. It's probably no surprise that eventually I became a therapist, too!

When and where do you write?

I write the weekly "Dear Therapist" column for The Atlantic, and I like the structure of that weekly schedule. I file on a certain day and edit on a certain day and that predictable rhythm suits me. Being a journalist has given me the gift of knowing how to write well on deadline, but also the curse of not being able to write without one! So for my magazine and newspaper pieces, I start early and am very focused on what I need to get done each day to meet my deadline. Writing books is another matter entirely. I generally have a year or more and my mind doesn't really know how to structure my days with such a long time horizon, so in month one, that seems like I have all the time in the world. Then before I know it, it's month six and I start to panic--oh, no! I have a BOOK due in six months! And then I put on my journalist hat and write on deadline, because six months is a more manageable deadline for me than a year or more.  I used to write best at midday. I'd take care of administrative things or errands in the mornings, and then I could write without worrying about what else I needed to get done or whom I needed to call back. But now, since I'm also a therapist with a practice, I don't always have the luxury of writing whenever I want to, or choosing the time of day that works best, so often I'm writing at night after my son goes to bed. 

What are you working on now?

I'm about to go on book tour for MAYBE YOU SHOULD TALK TO SOMEONE, and it seems like every interviewer has been asking that question. I wish I were the kind of writer who finishes one book, takes a couple of weeks off, and then starts working on the next project, but because I have the therapy practice and the weekly column, I can only focus on so much at once and I don't think people who aren't writers understand--or people who are writers talk about openly--that launching a book is a full time job. There's a period leading up to launch and then once the book is published in which you're going 24/7 with interviews and readings and media, and I know some people are able to be working on something else while talking about the book that just launched, but I'm not that skilled. Also, this book was so personal and in some ways the hardest thing I've ever written, and I want to sit with it and savor it for a while longer before I begin to think about where I go next. So what am I working on now? My weekly Atlantic column and my practice and trying to remind my son that yes, I do exist, even though it seems like I've disappeared these past few weeks.

Have you ever suffered from writer’s block?

Absolutely! In fact, MAYBE YOU SHOULD TALK TO SOMEONE was born of writers block, in that I was under contract to write a book that I just couldn't get myself to write. I spent several years staring at a blank page, writing words I didn't care about (when I did write), and pretending I was hard at work on the-book-I-wasn't-writing whenever people asked how it was going. I was like the gambler who kisses her spouse goodbye in the morning and then goes to the casino instead of the office. My casino was Facebook. Eventually, I mustered the courage to tell my editor I couldn't write this book, cancelled my contract, and began writing the book I should have been writing all along--this new one. A lot of people say that if something isn't working, you have to write through it, and while I know that can be true, sometimes it can also mean that you aren't working on the right story. 

What’s the best writing advice you’ve ever received?

An editor once told me that when I feel like I don't know how to start something or fix something and I'm banging my head against the wall, I should go outside and walk around the block and look at something green--trees, grass--and not think about whatever has me stuck. She said that resetting this way would help me get unstuck. And she was right. A lap or two around the block has worked 100% of the time. I always come back from those 10 or 15 minutes with something I didn't have in mind before I walked outside. It works well when writing books, too. Don't go on Twitter--just put on your shoes and walk outside.

What’s your advice to new writers?

Don't compare yourself to other people. Full stop.

Lori Gottlieb is a psychotherapist and New York Times bestselling author who writes the weekly “Dear Therapist” advice column for The Atlantic. She also writes frequently for The New York Times and has appeared on The Today Show, Good Morning America, CBS This Morning, CNN, and NPR.  Her most recent book is Maybe You Should Talk to Someone: A Therapist, Her Therapist, and Our Lives Revealed.  Learn more at LoriGottlieb.com or by following her @LoriGottlieb1 on Twitter.